This dissertation presents a comparison between NCU policy for Academic Integrity and business ethics. Both NCU policy for academic integrity and business ethics are codes of conduct. Can they be compared? Do the two have any similarities and differences? . By researching from books, online, journals and holding discussions with some business personnel’s about the two codes of conduct, I found out that the two codes of conduct have both similarities and differences. Some of the similarities are that both are codes of conduct that contain guiding principles, both in the North Central University and business respectively. Some of the differences that are discussed include their area of use, whereby, the UNC academic integrity policy is applied for North Central University students whereas the business ethics is meant for people in the business field went ahead to explain the importance of a code of conduct, the impact the code of conduct has on someone and the surrounding, and the importance of Proper citation in higher education and business. Key word: NCU policy for academic integrity, business ethics, codes of conduct.
COMPARE NCU POLICY FOR ACADEMIC INTEGRITY TO BUSINESS ETHICS
The NCU policy for academic integrity and business ethics are codes of conduct that are meant to guide and regulate human behavior in a university as well as business in general. So now the question is whether these two codes of conducts are comparable in any way. This would then mean that we have to look at the similarities and differences that are evident in these two codes of conduct .The North Central University policy for academic integrity is a document that contains ethics policies that all university students at North Central University must adhere to, lest they will face ill consequences like expulsion from school and receiving an F on assignment. These ethics policies act as a guide to regulating students conduct and behavior in the institution. Carroll A.B & Buchholtz A.K (2009) states that “doing what is right is expected and this applies to a wide range of academic situations”. On the other hand, business ethics are the guiding principles that regulate how the business operates in relation to its surroundings and individual clients. Failure to follow these guiding principles leads to fines on the business. The following is a comparison between the two codes of conduct.
To start with, both codes contain certain guiding principles that are supposed to guide peoples behavior in the university and people in the area of business respectively. The NCU policy for academic integrity is concerned with laying guidelines in the North Central University to ensure that what learners submit inform of projects, assignments and exams is out of their very own thinking and if they have to borrow ideas to support their arguments, then they must indicate that they have borrowed the ideas from another source by citing and referencing. Diane Dusick (Mgt 7019-1 ) states that “all work submitted in each course must be the learners own. This includes all assignments, exams, term papers and other projects required by the faculty mentor. The known submission of another person’s work represented as that of the learners without properly citing the source of the work will be considered as plagiarism and will result in an unsatisfactory grade for the work submitted or for the entire course and may result in academic dismissal”. This then
means that a student has to appreciate that he or she at time needs to borrow statements collected , collected data and any other kind of information from other sources by citing the work borrowed and referencing it correctly. Similarly, business ethics is concerned with laying guidelines on the way individuals and the business organization conducts itself in relation to the environment, while looking clearly at it’s moral guidelines and ethical issues that may come up in a business area.
The environment in this case may refer to another business or even the community at large. A case study of Wal-Mart by Carroll A.K & Buhholtz (2009) reveals that the single most notable challenge that Wal-Mart faces today is repairing it’s bad reputation and that across the country, local citizens are forming groups in an effort to stop the large Wal-Mart supercentres from ever gaining a foothold in their communities. The bad reputation of Wal-Mart is due to frequent violation of the business ethics. Currently, many businesses have created a bad reputation and Wal-Mart is just but one of them. The bad reputation is majorly due to the fact that most businesses just want to make money without taking into consideration the needs of the workers, customers or the effects that their business could have on the environment
Secondly, both NCU policy for academic integrity and business ethics explain clearly the consequences that are going to befall those who violate the set codes. For NCU, policy of academic integrity, it first outlines the exact behavior and conduct that will be regarded as academic dishonesty, and the consequences are then clearly outlined. According to www. ncsu.edu (pol11.35.1.php) academic dishonesty is defined as “the giving, taking or presenting information or material by student that unethically or fraudulently aids oneself or another on any work which is to be considered in the determination of a grade or in the completion of academic requirements enhancements of that student record on academic career”. This simply implies that in a situation where the student is required to carry out a task which may be an exam or a test solely, no one should assist him or her in answering the exam or the test and anyone who does so and is found out will be dismissed from the university. Similarly, when you violate business ethics codes which basically include commitment to obey laws and solving conflicting issues, you have to face the consequence, mostly of being fined heavily.
Another similarity between the NCU academic integrity policy and the business ethics is that both are written down policies and ethics, with NCU policy containing the codes of conduct at the North Central University and the business ethics containing codes of conduct in business.
The last similarity between NCU academic integrity policy and business ethics is that both can either affect an individual or the environment. For the NCU academic integrity policy someone who is caught being assisted to perform a task that is meant to be performed independently and the one who is caught assisting such a student all face the consequences of the code of conduct violation. For the Business ethics, a business which violates the code of conduct will face the consequences individually, but if another business associates with such a business organization, it also becomes unethical. A business can also affect the environment by selling items that emit poisonous substances to the atmosphere like ozone depleting substances.
One of the major differences between the NCU policy and business ethics is that the NCU academic integrity policy has set codes of conduct for North Central University students whereas the business ethics is meant to provide codes of conduct for universal business deals. Another difference between the two is in the consequences of violation of codes of conduct. For NCU policy, it leads to dismissal from school or the student being given an F in the assignment. However, for business ethics, the consequences of violating the law are usually fines that are in monetary terms. Due to this, we find that the business ethics policy can easily be compromised. This happens because if your business is doing well and is making great profits, even if you violate the business laws, you will pay the fines without feeling a pinch. What actually happens is that these fines only can punish small businesses that do not comply to the business ethics. What follows is that most times, we end up risking our own lives by compromising some of the business ethics, for example when the Wal-Mart company sold refrigerators that produce substances that were ozone depleting.
It’s important to note that a code of conduct is so important as it clearly outlines and explains the ethical behavior that is expected in institutions Thhey can be business institutions, academic institutions or any other kind of an institution. When faced with conflicts or crisis, one is able to refer to the codes of conduct so as to know how to deal with the situation. Basically, some of the items contained in codes include commitment to obey laws, solving conflicting issues and preserving confidential details. A code of conduct also states consequences that may follow a certain behavior. At the same time, a code of conduct impacts someone and his or her surrounding as it determines how you behave to those that surround you, how you relate to them and how you interact with the world. When we go to an environment that is regulated by certain kinds of conduct, we tend to observe how those people in that environment do things, how they behave and relate to each other and with no time, we get assimilated to their way of doing things and it even becomes part of our personality. So we can generally say that codes of conducts contribute to personality development.
The NCU policy of academic integrity policy and many other academic institutions insists that one should cite his or her work properly. Though at times citing may seem tasky, it’s a very important area in academic research as it prevents one from being accused of plagiarism. The only thing that can tell the difference between your own ideas and other people’s ideas is citing. This then means that the readers of your work will have easy time going out to search for the sources that you quoted incase they want further reference. As we have seen in the NCU policy of academic integrity, one of the repercussions for plagiarism is being dismissed from school. So to avoid putting yourself at a risk of heavy punishment, it’s necessary that one cites his or her work properly. At the same time, citing makes your work very interesting to read as the reader is able to relate your argument or ideas with another person’s ideas and way of reasoning, especially when you cite as you explain your ideas. The last reason as to why you need to cite your work, but not the least, is that when you cite your work, you create links through which you can even get someone to help you build your arguments further and thus strengthen your own ideas. This will in turn lead to growth and continuity of the discipline.
In conclusion, by carrying out intensive research, I found out that these two codes of conducts contain both similarities and differences, though it is clear that the similarities are more eminent than the differences. While the NCU policy for academic Integrity and the business ethics share a lot in common, the two codes of conduct contribute a lot to our societies. The NCU policy for academic integrity seeks to establish codes of conduct to ensure that what the learners submit in form of assignments, projects and term papers is out of their very own thinking and creativity. This is achieved by encouraging learners to do their own work and where they have to borrow ideas, then they have to cite the sources that they may use to support their work. On the other hand the business ethics provide a platform of codes of conduct from which businesses are run. Both codes of conduct have well explained consequences that befall those that violate these codes. For the NCU policy of academic integrity, students who violate this code are dismissed out of the university among other punishments and for those who violate the business ethics are usually heavily fined. Both codes of conduct are usually written down to ensure that every student at North Central University and every person interested in business is well conversant with the codes of conduct expected. However, the two codes of conduct differ in that the NCU policy of academic integrity is usually meant for students at North and Central University whereas the business ethics are universal and are meant for those people in business.
Now, since the differences between the two codes of conduct lie mainly on the scope of administration as well as the consequences that follow the violation of the codes, we can conclude that the NCU policy of academic integrity as well as the business ethics are comparable to a great extent but the similarities outweigh the differences.
Related Comparison essays
- Treatment of Community
- Comparison of Disney?s Peter Pan to the Return to Neverland
- The Meadow at Eragny and Riverbank at Lavacourt
- Research on Education in Countries Around the World
- A Focus on the Plays of Oscar Wilde and Joris-Karl Huysmans
- Article Summary
- Mac vs. PC
- Comparison of Nike and Adidas Websites
- Federalists and Anti-Federalists
- Comparing Two Historians